Madden NFL 27 Player Ratings: The Biggest Ratings, Rising Stars, and Players We’ve Lost

Madden NFL 27 player ratings offer more than just a list of numbers—they provide a fascinating snapshot of where the NFL stands in 2026. The coveted 99 Club features six players: Josh Allen, Ja’Marr Chase, Myles Garrett, Trey McBride, Jaxon Smith-Njigba, and Matthew Stafford. What makes this year especially interesting is the mix of generations. Stafford is entering his 18th NFL season and earned his first-ever 99 overall rating after an incredible 2025 season, while Jaxon Smith-Njigba and Trey McBride are first-time members who represent the next generation of NFL superstars. Garrett, meanwhile, earned his third 99 rating after setting the NFL single-season sack record with 23 sacks in 2025.

One of the most interesting parts of Madden 27 ratings is looking at the players who are no longer at the top of the game. Patrick Mahomes, Lamar Jackson, and other familiar Madden superstars have fallen out of the 99 Club, showing just how quickly the NFL changes. Mahomes, for example, sits at 92 in the current MaddenRatings database, while players such as Christian Gonzalez and George Kittle have climbed into the upper 90s. That creates an interesting contrast between the stars who once dominated Madden ratings and the players taking their place. The game is becoming a time capsule of the NFL, showing the transition from one generation of stars to another.

There are also some fascinating stories hidden deeper in the Madden NFL 27 ratings database. Desmond Watson, who is currently not on an NFL roster, reportedly carries a 96 Strength rating, demonstrating that individual attributes can sometimes be just as interesting as overall ratings. Players like Watson, along with veterans who have retired or fallen out of the league, remind us that Madden ratings aren't just about today's NFL—they can preserve pieces of past NFL eras. Meanwhile, young stars such as Smith-Njigba, McBride, Jahmyr Gibbs, Puka Nacua, and Christian Gonzalez are becoming some of the highest-rated players in the game.
​
That is what makes www.MaddenRatings.net more than simply a place to check whether a player is an 84 or a 94. Madden ratings tell the story of the NFL. They show which players are entering their prime, which veterans are hanging on, which young players are becoming superstars, and which familiar names have disappeared from the league altogether. Years from now, looking back at Madden NFL 27 will provide a fascinating snapshot of the football world in 2026—and the ratings themselves may tell an even bigger story than the game on the field.